School reform -- more success or stress?
Ohio Gov. Bob Taft's swan song -- or lame-duck dirge -- could have a big impact on your family life. If legislators agree with Taft, your teenager's school schedule will get tougher and, like it or not, he'll be taking far tougher math and science classes than you were ever required to take.
As our Sunday, Nov. 19, editorial says, it's the right thing to do -- too many Ohio kids have been allowed to plan schedules around comfort rather than intellectual challenge -- but it triggers many questions.
Does a tougher schedule require more time to master it? If so, can your family deal with a longer school year, longer school days, after-school tutorial programs?
Must adults recognize that higher standards equal more stress for already over-tested, over-measured, over-remediated kids? If so, do you worry how much more pressure your kids can take?
And does 'tightening the curriculum' -- when it is translated into daily life in the classroom -- really mean enriching it, or simply taking out the spontaneity and creativity that make learning truly meaningful?
Legislators will weigh cost versus benefit to the state. It's up to us parents to think about the effects on real kids.
2 Comments:
Thank goodness for home school - 2 of 4 of my kids have opted out of the traditional school. I wouldn't be surprised if another goes the way of home instruction.
One thing I don't understand - how are kids who just just have the intellectual capacity supposed to keep up? how are they supposed to feel good about their abilities when the bar keeps being raised on them?
Everyone seems to think that every kid has the same educational agility - they don't. But noone wants to accept that fact.
I think we need different opportunities for people with different abilities - wasn't that once the goal of trade schools? finding the talent, intrest and ability and educating to their ability instead of our desires?
I don't know.
Krista...The proposed new high school curriculum is nothing more than what was standard in the 50's.
Back in the dark ages when I attended a Chicago area public high school, the curriculum required four years of math (algebra through calculus), four years of English, four years of science (general science, chemistry, physics, biology), two years of a foreign language, two years of social studies/history and the balance being electives in music, art, etc.
Besides the rigors of the classroom where we worked our little tails off, many of my friends and I played in the school and community orchestra, the symphonic band, the marching band and worked on the weekly school newspaper and the school yearbook. We participated in State contests in science and music, went to all the football and basketball games and took in all the sock hops and more formal school dances and other social events.
We were not stressed out like today's wimpy high school students. We didn't have helicopter parents constantly hovering over us "helping" us, doing things we were supposed to do and wringing their hands in despair over our packed schedules.
We didn't even have editorial writers bemoaning our plight. What we did was quite normal by the standards of the day.
And guess what, Krista....none of us owned a car or even had access to one. We used something called public transportation....recall those odd-looking things called "buses"?
No TV's, no computers, no mp3 players, no cell phones, no PDA's, no CD's, no DVD's and no Internet. We didn't even have book bags or a 500 page spiral-ringed notebook for each subject!
How on Earth did we survive?
Here's how.
We...not mommy or daddy...we learned how to manage our own time efficiently. We enjoyed all our extra-curricular activities while managing to get all our homework/special projects done....and believe me, there was plenty of homework....and plenty of tests.
We all went on to college. Many went on to professional schools for advanced degrees. We enjoyed very productive professional careers while raising our families and participating in community affairs.
So....from the 50's to today. What has happened?
I have never seen so many wimpy parents and kids as I do today.
Today's kids would have never survived on their own in the 50's. They have neither the self-generated motivation nor the fortitude to complete a task.
They are the products of the Oprah age...where it is more important to feel good about yourself rather than to grow intellectually.
Today's kids are the products of the child-centered family where mommy and daddy give them everything their little spoiled heart desires in order to be their friends. This has prevented kids from making good choices on their own, accepting responsibilities, accepting the consequences of their decisions...in short,this has retarded the growing-up process where a child matures into an independent and functioning adult.
The new proposed high school curriculum...what a laugher. It's simply what was done 50 years ago....without the whining and complaining of today.
But what would any change be today without whining and complaining about it.
* Our online blogs currently are hosted and operated by a third party, namely, Blogger.com. You are now leaving the Cincinnati.Com website and will be linked to Blogger.com's registration page. The Blogger.com site and its associated services are not controlled by Cincinnati.Com and different terms of use and privacy policy will apply to your use of the Blogger.com site and services.
By proceeding and/or registering with Blogger.com you agree and understand that Cincinnati.Com is not responsible for the Blogger.com site you are about to access or for any service you may use while on the Blogger.com site. << Home