The danger of police work
The case of Cincinnati Police Sgt. Bryce Bezdek illustrates the everyday danger of police work.
Bezdek is a traffic officer. He doesn’t do undercover narcotics work or hunt down homicide suspects. His job is generally to keep the highways safe – go after speeders and drunk drivers, enforce the myriad traffic rules, investigate accidents.
But today he lies in critical condition at University Hospital with a head injury suffered Sunday afternoon when a car being pursued by other officers plowed through a blockade he was helping to set up.
One instant he’s out on the interstate doing his job, the next he’s near death.
He probably never saw the faces of the suspects in the speeding car that led police on a seven-mile, high speed chase. They were drug suspects, accused of shooting up heroin in a suburban parking lot. The car fled when officers tried to pull it over in Colerain Township. As it approached Downtown Cincinnati Bezdek and another officer were in the median, deploying “stop sticks” to flatten its tires. Police said the suspect driver, Carmella Duley, smashed into a pickup truck and sent it careening toward the officers. It hit Bezdek with such force that one of his uniform buttons was embedded in the truck’s door frame.
No TV-style glamour, no special effects or headline grabbing crime spree. Just people fleeing the law and a traffic sergeant doing his job to stop them. Our thoughts and prayers are with Sgt. Bezdek and his family.
29 Comments:
I agree with all of the good wishes going out to the officer and his family.
However, I thoroughly disagree with the policy of chasing the suspects at high speed. Innocent bystanders can and do get injured in these situations. I'd rather see a junkie in a shopping mall shooting up, from whom I can walk away, rather than having two high speed vehicles endangering me. Cars are weapons when used this way and if I were ever caught in this situation and injured I'd sue anybody and everybody.
Or at least save this tactic for armed robbers or such violent criminals. This was pointless.
-Joe Henke
I am one of Bryce Bezdek's bible bowlers and he has been and will always be a great person. I think that the officers did the right thing and I am so glad that they were able to stop the ba people because they need to see another way with Christ. Now I know that everyone is mad that these people for doing this but you know that God was there and is still there he will be working threw all of this to show people that he is the way the truth and the light. Well I hope everyone gets better from this and if something bad happens to Bryce then it happens but I know as well as others know that God has a place in heaven if needed at this time bryce will be able to dance with the angles and walk on streets made of gold. Well God bless and remember threw all of this God will be there for you and for everyone :)
What occurred in this instance that justified this high speed chase? Three individuals in a vehicle not moving, and let's assume the allegations of shooting up are true -- what danger to the individuals here, including the officers involved? These officers involved should have their licenses pulled - what next, indiscriminate firing of their weapons? Is there a difference between indiscriminate firing of weapons and a high speed chase? Ask this father: John Riggs and his daughter were injured in the crash. ""Granted that is a serious issue. I'm not tying to take away from that. But they are not threatening anybody's life," said Riggs. "They threatened a lot more lives by chasing her down the highway." http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21987287
Agree with the above poster.
While I don't wish the officer any harm, and hope the offenders are punished, I don't understand why this happened in the first place.
A high speed chase and stop sticks on a busy interstate for someone shooting up in a parking lot?
What happened to getting the license plate number and going after them later, for safety's sake? It's a hell of a lot safer than a high speed interstate chase with stop sticks.
And, unfortunately, this line of questioning regarding the necessity of the chase won't go anywhere.
As I'm sure we're all aware, cops can do no wrong. Suggesting such is not supporting the police or siding with lawlessness. It's an unfortunate situation.
Regarding David Wells Forum comments, first my prayers are with the Bezdek family. Secondly, did Mr. Wells see the cruiser cam video? Here is yet another example of the rabid pack dog mentality of those who are supposed to protect us. The officers involved in the chase put the lives of hundreds of innocent people in immediate mortal danger because some poor junkie decided to get their fix in a parking lot. The suspects were just that, suspects. Nobody was robbed, shot, or murdered. This was an unconscionable, reckless act by the police pursers and they should be held most accountable for Officer Bezdeks injuries. By the way, I grew up with and was friends with four people who became police officers, and had quite a few police officers who I played poker with regularly. I know more than a little about the police mentality, and have heard so many stories first hand from officers that would certainly never be made public, to know that though these are for the most part good people at heart, something happens when they put on the uniform and gun. Since this all began over suspected drug use, I think our satanizing of ILLEGAL drug users bears a look. According to our own governments statistics, well over fifty percent of the baby boom generation has used drugs. What this means is that your doctors, surgeons, judges, lawyers, teachers, priests, your mechanic you trust your car with, your trash collector, your air line pilot, someone who helps put this newspaper together, etc., oh and yes police officers, could very well have used drugs and may still use them occasionally. The President of the United States is an alcoholic and used illegal drugs much of his life! Though I have been clean and sober for over 23 years, I could give countless examples of well known and respected individuals here in town who were involved in not only the use but distribution of illegal drugs back in the 60's-80's. I won't even get into the drugs I did with police officers own kids. And yes, the officers knew about it. Funny how the perspective changes when it involves one of your own, or a friends. The suspects in the police pursuit are criminals according to our laws at present, but who was more of a danger to society that afternoon? I would not want the job of a police officer, and I think they should be compensated better, but I also believe there should be boundaries they can't cross, and be held fully accountable if they do. A pointless high speed chase such as this is just begging for a disastrous outcome like the one we witnessed. Enough said. Sincerely, Fred R. Knodle, Norwood Ohio
How many would be complaining if the officer had not given chase and this woman who was just seen injecting heroin had been allowed to go on her way, likely killing many others. She was not in an alley, or behind the mall. She was in a car, and then drove away. If she had then struck as civilian, the same "anonymous" people would be asking why the police didn't try to stop her. Can we not just pray for this brave and honorable man. A beloved son, brother, father, uncle, bible bowl coach, church deacon, USMC Veteran, and precious child of God? WE CAN! Is any of this criticism helping him or his family during this difficult time.
Thanks for front page story with the truck driver victim of this situation.
To Tom Streicher: If this is your first position/interview, OK. Later,"after careful investigation" I think you ought to come back and admit to the same conclusion everyone else has come to: bad decision. For once, just once, lose the bunker mentality and admit it.
Sounds like the junkie was going 80-90 miles per hour to get away from the cops and, even with her heroin addled brain, would have slowed down once the police/sheriffs did not give chase.....or not. Irrelevant; why have TWO high speed vehicles when getting a license plate number and doing some follow up might have been better police work - might have gotten a whole bunch of junkies in one spot, high, and ripe for the picking.
Heroin whores and junkies are as dangerous as anyone in society. To those who would "let'em get away", you are the enablers of the criminal scourge overtaking this community. Brazen individuals challenge the police at every corner, buffoonish activists hamstring the good officers doing their job protecting the community, yet many would rather let the criminal suspects go rather than enforce the law and protect public safety.
20-20 hindsight is a dangerous view.
To those who think "junkies" are harmless, how about the 3 "young citizens" who robbed and murdered the man at the motel off of 747 ?
We need more vigilance towards and less "tolerance" of criminal behavior.
To 4:01 nov 29 -
Agree in principle on crime, but no high speed car chases. They don't have to go together, and they shouldn't.
Reporters can't ever get stories correct. They only report what will create reactions out of people. What about the fact that this ignorant person driving the car disobeyed the law. She was already pulled over on the highway & as officers walked up & approached the car she sped off. She's the one who made the wrong decision. Why can't the reporters tell the facts & get it straight. She very well could have ran over one of those officers, killing them. Those officers involved had every right to chase the crazy son of a gun. If the officers didn't give chase & you or someone you know was injuried by this womens carelessness for society, you would be upset & going for those officers jobs. The police can't win. These officers did the right thing, no question. No policies where broken. It is a very sad situation, no question, about sgt. bezdek's injury. What's wrong with this city. Let's just show support & prayer for those injuried & stop pointing fingers of whether the right decisions were made. It's a shame sgt. bezdek's was not on the front page of the paper, only in the local section. You know, as well as me, if the criminal was hurt it would have been all over the front page of the paper. That's what is wrong with this city. The reporters/editors are responsible for a lot of the tension here, & until things can be handled properly things will never change.
Anonymous @ 5:08 - You throw 'if' around like it was candy. If frogs had wings - well, you know the rest. Here's a 'if' for you -- if the officers had not given chase this wreck might not have happened at all, lives might not have been put in danger, Officer Bezdek might not be seriously injured and all might be well with the world. What it comes down to, 5:08,is the so-called War on Drugs is a spectacular abject failure. Tax payers are paying for thrill rides like this for police and I, for one, am damned tired of paying the tab for the damage done.
12:48
She was on heroin and trying to escape. Any number of deaths/ injuries could've resulted from inaction.
"Letting 'em go" when they are strung out on drugs and behind the wheel... I don't think so !
8:13, get a brain. this chase was not b/c of a so called war on drugs. the chase happened b/c the suspect made the wrong decision to sped off & fun from the law. no one's above the law - no one!! carmella duley was not stopping no matter what, until she got home. she knew she was being watched, & only was thinking of herself.
As a police officer, here is my suggestion - Follow the advice of fools and stop all police chases. Have Mark Mallory, Si Leis and every Police Chief throughout Hamilton County hold a press conference and reassure the public they will keep them safe by not pursuing people who choose to place lives in danger with their reckless disregard of the law.
After a couple of years of the new policy, the vast majority of the public will realize the foolishness of it all and throw such misguided policies into the trash bin where they belong.
Imagine if the suspect in this case had begun indiscriminately firing a weapon rather fleeing in a car. The danger created would have been the same but everyone would have agreed that the police should have intervened and called for their removal if they hadn't.
The world we live in is often a dangerous one. We cannot contol, nor are we responsible for the actions of others.
Those injured in this incident have only the suspect to blame and no one else.
10:02 - get a clue. Duley was parked, not moving, when the clusterscrewup began and the police started it. In this and so many events the police are part of the problem and not part of the solution.
Whoever posted the comments at at 1:51 is right on the money. The car was parked. Furthermore, the vast majority of people would agree with you that this situation was both controlled and initiated by the Sherrifs dept.
Last but not least, Officer Tim Holloway sounds to me like he's more a part of the problem than the solution. Cincinnati has become a NAZI state due in large part to the actions and wishes of the Hamilton County Sherrifs Dept.
really, get a clue .... think about what you are saying, "the car was parked." do you think she was going to sit there until she sobered up? not quite. strung out on heroin, as soon as they were finished shotting up, they would have pulled their car right out on the street. i can honestly say, i was in the colerain area as well as on 75 on saturday. driving along with my husband and 1 year old, i am sure glad to know i have the cops out there monitoring and keeping the roads safe. this accident was not their fault, it was plain and simple carmella duley's. she shot up, she drove off and she resisted arrest.
many of you out there drive regularly down 75 at 80-90 mph. just because the cpd and hcsd were invovled driving these speeds many of you are quick to point the finger. maybe you should think about your loved ones. if carmella duley hit their car you sure would be angry when there was a police report about this women shooting up in a parking lot and they did nothing about it. you would be the first one's to blame the police for ignoring a harmful situation and not taking care of what should be done.
you all should be happy these men put their lives on the line for us everyday dealing with individuals like carmella duley making bad choices. cops do have crazy stories about people they deal with and situations they get involved in. so do i. i am a teacher and i have crazy things happen with students all the time. i have a wealth of bizarre stories and crazy situations that occur. however, i still get up each day and do my job to the best of my ability just as they do.
right now maybe you all should just put a little more effort into praying for bryce, his wife, his children, his family, all the police officers affected by this incident, and all the police officers that keep us safe each day.
this was a situation in whic
Why all or none? Sometimes a chase may be necessary. This time, not.
Everybody knows (and I hope, respects) that the police are the brave, fine blue line between criminals and the rest of us. They just don't have a gold plated pass to do whatever they want all the time. Nobody does. So if they were to be gently reproved and their playbook ammended by their supervisors, and they can't take the criticism, then they're bad EMPLOYEES.
Nobody is perfect, and if you choose this job, then you gotta take the good with the bad. Otherwise sit behind a desk with the rest of us boring folks.
I was teh first poster, and I say again. If you ever cause me to be injured with a car, a gun, or anything else, when another, more moderate approach could have been deemed suitable, I'll sue the police department, the city, etc.
No disrespect to you Mr. Holloway, in fact, it's an opportunity to thank you most sincerely for your dedication. But your boss, needs to look at the rule book and make some intelligent adjustments. (I know it was sheriffs, but I'm just making a point).
First lets get the correct story out there. Yes the car was in the parking lot , but when officers arrived they were updated that the vehicle had exited eastbound ronald regan. One Sheriff's deputy saw the vehicle about the 7.9 milepost e/b R.R. Suspect vehicle made two moving violations which were unsafe lane (almost striking vehicle behind them) and and following to close to vehicle infront of the suspect vehicle. The Deputy turned his lights on at the 9.6 milepost with suspect vehicle finally stopping at the 10.2 milepost. When two deputies started walking up to the vehicle the suspects fled the traffic stop. Deputies went after vehicle which someone of you should look up in the o.r.c is called fail to comply with police officer. after suspect vehicle kept going cutting traffic off and almost causing accidents this turned into a felony and the suspect was using the vehicle as a weapon (just like a gun,car's kill too) which makes its the officers job to try all means to stop the vehicle before the general public can be harmed.(Last time I checked thats what the police use are tax payer dollars to do)Officers and dipatch were not getting any info from the vehicle tag to determine who was driving the vehicle or if it was correct tag or stolen i.e. more resons the pursuit had to keep going. there was no pack going on only other officers from both c.p.d and h.c.s.o trying to help the two deputies stop this fleeing felon.yes it is terrible what happened to Sgt.Bezdek but he was doing his job like any other officer would have done,and by this suspects willful actions he fighting for his life. no one is to blame except camella duley and the two junkies in the car. if you want the full story and stop listening to the media who only wants to get a bad reaction from the public, wait for all reports from o.s.p ,c.p.d and h.c.s.o to come out ,and infom yourself before you make incorrect comments. lastly pray for Sgt.Bezdek to fully recover and for the officers who saw this accident first hand it gave them all a reminder of what could happen everyday they put on the uniform.also if possible make any donation you can to 5/3rd for Sgt.Bezdek and his family
oh, c'mon, 9:26 - quit spinning the story and making up hypotheticals and imagine if (your favorite word) Duley had simply slowly driven home and not harmed anyone. No story. But instead we've got cowboys chasing her -- no INSTIGATING a high speed chase that ended in tragedy. Ok - you want Duley to be responsible, she's responsible - but in proportion to the damage, the cowboy cops here are at least equally responsible.
And now perhaps you should argue with Cincinnati police, anon @ 9:26 and Tim Holloway. "As Hamilton County Sheriff's deputies chased a sport utility vehicle full of suspected drug users down Interstate 75 at speeds reaching 90 mph, Cincinnati police commanders were telling their officers to back off.
The reason was that, in Cincinnati police pursuit policies, drugs aren't enough cause for a high-speed chase.
"There were supervisors who did not feel that our officers should be engaged in a pursuit based on what was put out," Harrell said.
In fact, those supervisors instructed a number of Cincinnati officers not to get involved for that reason." http://www.wlwt.com/news/14733391/detail.html?subid=10100221
ok, i am 9:26 and maybe those of you that disagreed with me should read 11:57. she was pulled over for traffic violations, not for doing drugs. i was not spinning the story and i do believe your situation in which 'camella duley drove home and made it there safely' is just as much a hypothetical. that never happened. i sincerely hope people like carmella do not come across your loved ones on the highway.
i know you will never see any other side of the story. if you are going to make as crazy of a statement as "cowboy cops" you are not worth everyone's time. to try and have a conversation with you about this is not practical. maybe those of us who realize what the police did, cpd and hcso, and are trying to talk with you about this and make sense of the situation should just spend our time praying for officer bezdek, his family, and the rest of the police. you are obviously not worth a breath of air. just remember all that you have said here when the police save your life someday. maybe that's what it will take for you understand what good they did here.
11:34, of course you would sue. that's all you seem to care about. i'm ashamed to live in the world we do. anymore, anyone & everyone is looking for a reason to sue. give me a break!
WOW! Good thing blogs don't come with guns, we'd have a massacre right here!
Let's try to make sense of this. First, we HAVE to respect the police. They do a job some people wouldn't even do for their own families; they risk their lives to protect ours. Second, they HAVE to respect us. That means trying to be as safe as possible with the lives of innocent bystanders while they do their job. Without these two things, we're toast.
Third, if this car was originally parked, did anyone think of using cars to block their exitway? Fourth, same question during the traffic stop...why not block the escape route with a second car in front of the offender? Maybe this suggestion can make things safer moving forward...I dunno, I'm not a cop. But I know a smashed up car is a lot less expensive to replace than a smashed-up cop or bystander.
Finally, and most importantly, best wishes for a full recovery to the injured officer.
Pray for the life and family of the CPD Officer. Now first to second guess what happened is just like the public of know it alls on what everybody else should've done in this matter, fact is police pursuits are going to happen and to say that "she was only shooting up" is just plain stupid. She is a scourge on our society and drug user who could've killed any number people or caused a major accident. Her actions of using drugs and fleeing the scene when pulled over caused the crash which in turn severly injured the CPD Officer thus it is her fault and she is responsible for her actions and choices (choosing to run from the police), to say they should have let her go probably comes from the mouths of people who dislike the police in the first place but will be the first ones calling when things go wrong and also shows their lack knowledge in police and legal matters. Some of you would have sued... sure ya would as is just one more case of the get-rich-quick mentality seen all over today. Let's just hope its not your family struck by a drug user or drunk driver the next time, especially if the police aren't involved. As for getting the plate number it could've turned out that she would say it wans't her in the car or any other number of lies to get outta trouble, do you really think a drug user would've said "yes officer I was shooting up in the parking lot" be real people.
Officer Holloway has a point - remember how police work changed after the riots when the police became the scapegoats instead of the heroes?
We are just now getting back on track with cracking down on criminals and here we go again criticizing their choices.
Stop 2nd guessing every move they make. None of us are experts unless we have actually been police officers ourselves.
"Pay no attention to that man behind the curtain" -- right, 12/5 at 3:22? Ignore what's right in front of you, let the police tell you what happend and accept it unquestioningly - right, 2/5 at 3:22? Go away and drink your hemlock flavored kool aid.
Suing is a wake up call when used judiciously. And it's only money, which I would use to pay my medical expenses or feed my family if I couldn't. I agree about egregious law suits, but that's come about because we have too many attorneys, I think, maybe. Even that I can understand; have you never wanted your kid to maybe be a doctor or lawyer, considered a step up in most societies?
But don't be ashamed for me. That's arrogant. I think through everything I say before I say it - learned that the hard way. So, yes, I would sue if I needed the money and my life were irrevocably changed by someone else's wretched excess.
Happy holidays to all. There's been a lot of anguished goodness posted here.
* Our online blogs currently are hosted and operated by a third party, namely, Blogger.com. You are now leaving the Cincinnati.Com website and will be linked to Blogger.com's registration page. The Blogger.com site and its associated services are not controlled by Cincinnati.Com and different terms of use and privacy policy will apply to your use of the Blogger.com site and services.
By proceeding and/or registering with Blogger.com you agree and understand that Cincinnati.Com is not responsible for the Blogger.com site you are about to access or for any service you may use while on the Blogger.com site. << Home