Classroom cops not the answer
Butler County Sheriff Richard Jones, who has been nurturing a reputation as the toughest sheriff on illegal immigration north of the Rio Grande, now proposes a way to keep maniacs from unleashing mayhem on college campuses.
In a letter to Ohio Gov. Ted Strickland, Thursday, Sheriff Jones proposed a “mandatory armed law enforcement presence at all schools.”
The sheriff notes in a Friday story by reporter Jon Craig that his proposal “will not come without a price tag.”
I’ll say.
According to the Ohio Department of Education Web site, there are 3,623 public schools and at least 877 non-public schools in the state of Ohio. That’s 4,500 separate schools. If you were to put just one armed police officer in each of those buildings, you would need a force roughly four and a half times the size of the Cincinnati Police Department. And that doesn’t count colleges and universities.
State Rep. Courtney Combs, R-Fairfield, said in the story he will consider sponsoring legislation to train teachers to carry guns, who Jones suggested could then be “deputized” to protect the kids in the classrooms.
“It needs to be debated,” Combs said in the story.
No it doesn’t.
In the wake of the Virginia Tech shootings we all want to find some way to keep it from happening again. It is every parent’s nightmare to learn that you have sent a child off to someplace you think is safe, only to learn that the unthinkable has happened. We all want to protect our children. I don’t blame Jones or Combs for suggesting putting cops in every classroom or arming teachers – but that isn’t the way.
It should be remembered that Virginia Tech had its own police department. Several officers already were on the scene of the initial shooting in a dormitory when the second, more extensive incident took play across campus in another building.
No police officer, or group of police officers, could possibly cover every possible location where a shooting might occur. Police are reactive – they are called after the crime has occurred. The way to address keeping another Virginia Tech from happening is to be pro-active; to recognize the danger of a ticking bomb like Cho Seung-Hui and try to defuse it before it goes off.
4 Comments:
Let's not temp fate by putting guns in schools on purpose. Murphy's Law will appear and we'll be saddened again due to the ill advised, controversy mongering Sherriff of BC
A more practical and valuable lifetime experience would be to educate all students how to individually and collectively better protect themselves when confronted by shooter(s) or bomber(s) in the future.
Rather than run and be shot in the back one by one, rather than cower and lie behind a desk and be shot one by one; possibly, collectively charging a crazed killer with books and furniture in hand would enable a group to overpower and prevent mass slaughters. Some heroes will die in this group assault of self defense on the crazed gunman.
There is no single solution or system to protect our kids for life from all dangers. But I do want my kid trained on how better to protect and defend herself.
A cop in every building and classroom is impractical. Allowing an absentminded professor to carry a firearm to school seems too risky. Crazed students would just be able to steal the teachers' gun.
Putting armed officers in every school is not only financially improbable, but not a strategic way to stop school shootings. Financially, many districts are having problems getting a levy passed to keep day to day operations going. Asking districts, and all of it's citizens in the district, to put out the amount of money that would be needed to support this would be a large waste of money since, unless there was an officer at the end of every hallway and at every door to the building, there would be no way to ensure that shootings would never happen.
As far as giving guns to teachers, this is even more ridiculous. All it would take is one student to get a hold of the gun, or one stressed out teacher and making a comment about having a gun to a misbehaving student to show this was a bad idea.
There are 4,500 schools in Ohio alone. Let me just say that school shootings are a tragedy that cannot be put into words alone. Realistically how many, percentage wise, have actually occurred based on the number of schools in this country. Not many. Now let's look at how many warning signs are shown by these shooters before they kill anyone. In most, if not all the school shootings, there have been warning signs of instability and most have been ignored or thought to be not important. What we need to educate students, parents, teachers, and society in general, so that we can help these people before they do something that creates another tragedy.
Mark Altherr...What we need to educate students, parents, teachers, and society in general, so that we can help these people before they do something that creates another tragedy.
Fine, if you are able to ID those students that need help, give them help in a controlled environment off campus and out of the general public classroom.
I don't want your experiments running loose on campus and in my kids' classrooms. The hell with their privacy rights, if they are a danger to others.
* Our online blogs currently are hosted and operated by a third party, namely, Blogger.com. You are now leaving the Cincinnati.Com website and will be linked to Blogger.com's registration page. The Blogger.com site and its associated services are not controlled by Cincinnati.Com and different terms of use and privacy policy will apply to your use of the Blogger.com site and services.
By proceeding and/or registering with Blogger.com you agree and understand that Cincinnati.Com is not responsible for the Blogger.com site you are about to access or for any service you may use while on the Blogger.com site. << Home