Today's dinosaurs walk with tourists
I don't have any problem with the taxpayer-supported Northern Kentucky Convention & Visitors Bureau's Web site listing the Creation Museum as a local attraction. One thing is for sure about the museum -- it's an attraction that draws tourists.
But I also understand why scientists, taxpayers and others who don't accept the fundamental premise of the Creation Museum have a problem with the way the attraction is portrayed on the site. (Here's a link.) That premise, you'll recall, is that dinosaurs and humans were together on the Earth only a few thousand years ago. This is, at best, a controversial belief that even many Christian skeptics of evolution reject.
What stirred Daniel Phelps, head of the Kentucky Paleontological Society, was the statement on the site that "this 'walk through history' museum will counter evolutionary natural history museums that turn countless minds against Christ and Scripture."
Pat Frew of the convention bureau countered that content comes from the attractions themselves since they know best what is at their venues. Here's a link to our story, which also contains links to comments from both sides.
Frew's point makes sense probably 99 percent of the time. But this isn't just any attraction either. Because there is no attribution, the wording makes it sound as though this is the position of the convention bureau on this controversial subject. And it's hard to imagine the Cincinnati Museum Center having a promotional paragraph attacking another museum.
The answer seems pretty simple. The bureau should say on its Web pages and in its other promotional materials that venue descriptions are provided by the attractions.
I've met some of the Creation Museum leaders. They're bright people who feel genuinely called to do what they do. They respond openly to criticism and obviously are savvy marketers. They've earned some grudging respect from their critics. And, because this is America, I definitely appreciate having the right not to accept all the Creationist views.
5 Comments:
Whatever the Convention Bureau is allowing this museum to say about themselves, it couldn't compare to the travesty across the river where Cincinnati taxpayers were forced to give $800,000 to The Freedom Center. If the Creation Museum is willing to continue trying this novel concept called supporting themselves, I won't complain about anything they do.
I hope Jeff Berding and Leslie Ghiz don't read this, or else they might try to give the Creation Museum an $800,000 subsidy themselves to match the money they wasted on The Slave Center.
I'm not quite sure what the above poster is getting at, but I strongly agree with Mr. Hetzel that the NKCVB needs to make some adjustments to its website.
Its current description of the Creation Museum is unconstitutional. Because tax dollars comprise a significant portion of NKCVB's operating budget, it is a "state actor" for purposes of constitutional analysis. As such, the NKCVB is required to abide by the constitution's mandates as would any other governmental entity.
As it's currently written, the website's description of the Creation Museum probably violates the First Amendment's Establishment Clause, which forbids governmental entities from endorsing a particular religion. Because the website does not attribute the speech at issue to the Creation Museum, it reasonably appears that the NKCVB itself is making the assertion that other museums "turn countless minds against Christ and Scripture." This is a clear example of an unconstitutional "endorsement" of relgion.
As Mr. Hetzel points out, the NKCVB could rectify this problem by simply stating a conspicuous message that the various descriptions of the attractions listed on its websites are provided by the attractions themselves. Or, perhaps the better solution would be for NKCVB to demand from the Creation Museum a more neutral description of the museum which does not denigrate other local attractions like the Cincinnati Museum Center.
Like the "Creation Museum", the kimodo dragon exhibit at the Cincinnati Zoo is also an area tourist attraction with dangerous reptiles, and the same rules should apply-- watch all you want, but don't fall in!
__It appears that Dennis Hetzel negates his argument in the 2nd paragraph. Has he concludes that, "That premise, you'll recall, is that dinosaurs and humans were together on the Earth only a few thousand years ago.". A conclusion based on Daniel Phelps misguided intepretation of a statement on the museums website. It seems as though they view the word Christ, and limit the evolutionary time to the era Christ was among us in physical form. The Word was with the Father in the beginning, and scripture dates back long before Christ physically walked among us. So that argument, to say the museums website is issuing false statements is busted. Taxes support the Northern Kentucky Convention & Visitors Bureau's Web site listing the Creation Museum. Just as American taxes support many, many, other areas of national, state, and community activity. Why don't we start allowing taxpayers to pick, and chose, where their tax dollars go? If I follow Dennis Hetzel logic, "because this is America, I definitely appreciate having the right not to accept all" the government funded abortions. Get real children, if you don't like it don't read it.
JohnDWoodsjr you failed to understand the point once again. The Cin Zoo is subsidized by 10+ million per year, through endowments, levies, and capital drives. Oopps!
* Our online blogs currently are hosted and operated by a third party, namely, Blogger.com. You are now leaving the Cincinnati.Com website and will be linked to Blogger.com's registration page. The Blogger.com site and its associated services are not controlled by Cincinnati.Com and different terms of use and privacy policy will apply to your use of the Blogger.com site and services.
By proceeding and/or registering with Blogger.com you agree and understand that Cincinnati.Com is not responsible for the Blogger.com site you are about to access or for any service you may use while on the Blogger.com site. << Home