'The miracle of this moment'
Those who did not get a chance to read Sunday’s Your Voice column by Rabbi Abie Ingber should go back and savor his wise words. In “Treasure American-flavored Christmas,” he speaks lovingly about how he, his family and friends embrace each other's religious traditions and celebrations, from teaching Christian friends to spin the dreidel to sharing a joke with a Muslim friend about Ramadan fasting.
Ingber sees this as an inherent virtue in our American culture, a source of blessing. “Ours is an amazing country. We have built a culture that is Western, yet is open to every ethnic and religious community,” he writes. “We have found a way to share our differences in laughter and hope without any thought of one-upmanship.”
You know, he’s right. By and large, we have. The vast majority of Americans treat each other with respect, openness and caring. So why is it that what we hear and read about is mostly the noisemakers, the haters or the exploiters? Why are their voices so much larger than their actual importance in our lives?
This profession, as it were, is a culprit. The media thrive on conflict, on squeaky wheels, on false dichotomies, on reducing complex, subtle arguments to sound bites and headlines, on good guys and bad guys and black-and-white issues. Real life isn’t often like that.
Each of us is a jumble of noble impulses and not-so-noble weaknesses. But most of us have acquaintances of different cultures, religions, ethnicities and political persuasions. We work, eat, celebrate and play with them. We sit on the bus and chat with them. We cheer for our team with them.
Yes, there are many problems, Ingber says, and Americans must do more to break down barriers among us. “But we have done an incredible job in changing the face of the world in a little more than two centuries,” he writes. Think about that for a minute. Where would the world be without this American experiment?
After submitting his column, Ingber sent me an e-mail thanking me for deciding to publish it – although it was I who should have been thanking him. He ended the note with this comment: “We live in a wonderful corner of the world at a most incredible time – and rarely notice the miracle of this moment.”
Take a moment to notice the everyday miracle we sustain and nurture without fanfare. Blessed holidays to you, Rabbi, and to all of us.
3 Comments:
Dear Ray Cooklis,
I really enjoyed reading your comments.
Also, I believe that there are lots of people who have positive messages, however they often don't have the means to deliver that message to lots of people at the same time. But, personal experience has taught me that there is no better way to communicate with people than one person at a time. Have a nice holiday season.
The world could use a few more people like Rabbi Abie Ingber.
Jim Parker
Former Democratic Candidate for US Congress
Southern Ohio - 2nd District - 2005 & 2006...
(Adams, Brown, Clermont, Hamilton, Pike, Scioto and Warren Counties)
Ray, your write the following:
"So why is it that what we hear and read about is mostly the noisemakers, the haters or the exploiters? Why are their voices so much larger than their actual importance in our lives?
This profession, as it were, is a culprit. The media thrive on conflict, on squeaky wheels, on false dichotomies, on reducing complex, subtle arguments to sound bites and headlines, on good guys and bad guys and black-and-white issues."
My question to you is simply this. If you know you are the culprit, why don't you change?
Why are you so wedded to the assumption that journalistic dissonance is what the public wants when, in fact, it is not what the public wants?
Are you kidding, Ray. Let me explain your business to you...
The greater your circulation, the more you charge for advertising, subscriptions are cheap for this reason. (Name any other thing that you can get delivered to your doorstep for 50 cents a day).
In order to keep people subscribing (even for a pittance) they have to perceive that they would lose something if they discontinued their subscription.
The surest way to do that is to include mostly sensational negative stuff that makes the reader feel good about themselves and scoff at the fools other people are.
Of course, if the reader were to realize that he/she is not that different from the "other people" and has foibles of his/her own that, given the proper circuimstances, could result in their being the target of the mass aduience, the game would be up.
The Rabbi is simply stating that we should spend more time celebrating our similarities and far less time judging one another for our differences.
Great message, but won't sell many papers. Ghandi and King weren't big in the press until there was riots and troops and violence.
* Our online blogs currently are hosted and operated by a third party, namely, Blogger.com. You are now leaving the Cincinnati.Com website and will be linked to Blogger.com's registration page. The Blogger.com site and its associated services are not controlled by Cincinnati.Com and different terms of use and privacy policy will apply to your use of the Blogger.com site and services.
By proceeding and/or registering with Blogger.com you agree and understand that Cincinnati.Com is not responsible for the Blogger.com site you are about to access or for any service you may use while on the Blogger.com site. << Home